On a frosty winter morning, when walking to your car and finding iced-over windows, you need an ice scraper that quickly and reliably provides a clear view. At the beginning of this year, TCS extensively tested nine different ice scrapers. The most crucial criterion, naturally, was the effectiveness of ice removal, which significantly influenced the evaluation. Handling, build quality, safety, and additional features of the ice scrapers were also tested.
The test conducted by TCS experts revealed that all nine ice scrapers performed their tasks, and the differences were not very significant. However, the X-Treme model was a clear winner, achieving 85 out of 100 points. The X-Treme ice scraper impressed with effective and quick ice removal. It's a simple and robust ice scraper that performed its task effortlessly. At a purchase price of 4.50 Swiss francs on the survey date, it was also the second cheapest among the tested ice scrapers. The ProPlus and Walser models also scored more than 80 percent and were rated as 'excellent'. While the ProPlus ice scraper impressed with its compact form, the Walser model offered additional features like a cleaning rubber. However, at 24.95 Swiss francs, it was significantly more expensive than the simpler models.
The other six models scored between 79 and 60 points and were rated as 'highly recommended'. It was notable that the Kärcher ice scraper scored 60 points, yet at a purchase price of 54.90 Swiss francs on the survey date, it was the second most expensive. The Kärcher ice scraper removes ice using an electric rotatable disc with plastic blades. While this ensures safe handling, it is very slow, and due to the complex construction, it is also sensitive to impacts and falls.
The TCS test showed that essentially all models provide frost-free windows. Differences primarily lay in the core performance: how quickly and effectively the devices remove ice. It turned out that especially simple, robust, and cost-effective ice scrapers deliver very good results. Those looking for additional features will also find a wide variety of models available on the market.
The most important tips for
frost-free windows:
- Snow should be removed before scraping to avoid scratches on the glass surface.
- Apply even pressure when removing ice and avoid jerky movements.
- Remove thick ice gradually.
- Ice sprays can be used to assist, but they do not replace the ice scraper.
- Hot water should not be used for de-icing, as it can cause stress cracks or glass breakage.
- Running the engine during de-icing can result in a fine.
Press contact:
Marco Wölfli, TCS Media Spokesperson
Tel. +41 58 827 34 03
marco.woelfli@tcs.ch